Ratigan Capital
Join the lab list

14 / Failed breakout — this one did not hold

A close through a March high, then a stop that would have been hit

BTC/USD, daily. Price closed through a clearly marked swing high, then the very next sessions gave the breakout back and undercut the breakout day’s low. This is the example of a breakout that does not hold.

Educational examples — not a trade Josh took, not a signal

A pale blue walkway whose far section has separated and dropped, a calm picture of an idea that did not hold.
Illustration of the idea, not a market chart and not a result.

BTC/USD · daily · 2026-02-25 to 2026-03-28. Data: Kraken public OHLC API. Fills, fees and slippage are not known from these bars. Hypothetical study figures on this page are untested.

Related glossary: failed breakout, breakout, invalidation.

Bitcoin daily candlesticks from 25 February to 28 March 2026. A dashed blue line marks the 4 March high of 74,062.10 and a teal dashed line marks the 16 March low of 72,304. Annotations mark the 16 March close at 74,887.70 through the high, the 17 March high at 75,998.10, the 18 March low at 70,500 through the 16 March low, and the 27 March low at 65,519.70.
BTC/USD daily, 25 February–28 March 2026. The blue dashed line is the 4 March high of $74,062.10. The teal dashed line is the 16 March low of $72,304.00, the untested invalidation in the study logic below. Source: Kraken public OHLC API.
What this Failed breakout above a swing high example shows
What the setup showsOn 4 March 2026 Bitcoin’s high was $74,062.10 (close $72,684.80). A nearby 13 March high was $73,928.50. On 16 March it closed at $74,887.70, through the 4 March high, after a low that day of $72,304.00 (high $74,901.30). On 17 March the high was $75,998.10 and the close was $73,929.90, already back below the 4 March high. On 18 March the low was $70,500.00 (close $71,270.90), through the 16 March low.
Hypothetical study logic (untested)A study of a “buy a close through the 4 March high” might treat the 16 March close of $74,887.70 as interest, with invalidation below that day’s low of $72,304.00. Planned risk would be $2,583.70 (1R). An illustrative 2R target would sit at $80,055.10. Untested, and a daily close is not a known fill.
What price did afterwardsThe 17 March high of $75,998.10 was $1,110.40 above the 16 March close, about 0.43R, and that session already closed back at $73,929.90. On 18 March the low of $70,500.00 undercut the untested $72,304.00 stop. The 2R figure of $80,055.10 was not reached in this window. On 27 March the low was $65,519.70 (close $66,358.30).
What could go wrongExactly this: a close through a swing high can fail immediately. The 17 March close back under the 4 March high was already a warning, and the 18 March low would have hit a stop under the 16 March low. Seeing only the 17 March high without also recording the stop-out would be cherry-picking. A single failed breakout is not a sample and is not an edge for fading breakouts either.
Josh shrugging, as if to mark a habit to avoid.

Josh explains

A walkthrough of this example

This is narration of the published facts on this page. It does not add new numbers, and it is not a signal.

  1. Josh pointing as he explains an idea.

    Step 1

    What the chart is showing

    Bitcoin daily, March 2026: a close through a prior high, then a stop in this untested study that would have been hit. This page is here because the breakout failed. Read the 16 March close, the 17 March close back under the high, and the 18 March low that undercut the untested stop.

  2. Josh thinking, with a hand on his chin.

    Step 2

    The untested study idea

    A “buy a close through the high” sketch is on the page, labeled untested. The later 2R figure was not reached in this window. The 17 March high, taken alone, would have looked fine. The close and the next low tell the rest.

  3. Josh holding up a caution hand.

    Step 3

    What to take from it

    Exactly this: a close through a swing high can fail immediately. Seeing only the favorable high without also recording the stop being hit is how a failed breakout becomes a success story. I want this example next to the ones that held.

Join the lab list

Occasional notes about this public lab — new pages and implementation notes. Not signals, not a membership account, and not an application.

The list is not open yet. This form does not collect or send your address. When it opens, a consent line and the privacy policy will apply.

Education only, not financial advice. This is a personal record of one trader’s decisions, including the mistakes. Trading crypto carries a real risk of losing money. Full disclaimer.